BuyInsured.org, It’s insured!

Comparison

Fixed index annuity vs. MYGA

Both protect your principal from market losses. One gives you a known rate. The other gives you a shot at more, with no guarantee of getting it.

Key points

  • Both protect principal from market losses.
  • MYGA: guaranteed fixed rate, simple and predictable.
  • FIA: index-linked growth with caps and a 0% floor.
  • FIAs often offer income riders; MYGAs rarely do.
MYGA: same rate every yearFIA: index-linked, 0% in down years

How each one credits interest

A MYGA (multi-year guaranteed annuity) pays a fixed rate, set on day one, for the whole term. Today that is up to 6.25%. You know exactly what you will have at the end.

A fixed index annuity (FIA) credits interest based on the performance of a market index such as the S&P 500, subject to limits set by the carrier: a cap (the most you can earn in a period), a participation rate (the share of the index gain you receive) or a spread. If the index falls, you are credited 0% for that period rather than a loss. Index dividends are not included.

Side by side

MYGAFixed index annuity
ReturnGuaranteed fixed rateIndex-linked, limited by caps or participation rates
Down marketsNo effectCredited 0% (no loss from index declines)
PredictabilityExact value known in advanceVaries year to year
Typical terms2 to 10 years5 to 10+ years
ComplexitySimpleSeveral moving parts; carrier can change caps at renewal
Income ridersRareOften available for an added fee

Which suits you?

A MYGA tends to suit savers who want certainty, often money being moved from CDs or savings. A fixed index annuity tends to suit savers with a longer horizon who want some participation in market growth without downside risk and are comfortable with variable results, or who want a guaranteed lifetime income rider.

Neither is “better” in general. The right answer depends on your time horizon, how you would feel about a 0% year, and whether you need lifetime income.

Why MYGAs look strong right now

When interest rates are higher, MYGA guarantees rise and the certainty of a fixed 6.15% for five years can compete well with the expected crediting of many index strategies. When rates are low, FIAs often look relatively more attractive. Tom can show you a current MYGA rate and an FIA illustration side by side.

Frequently asked questions

Is a fixed index annuity better than a MYGA?

Neither is better for everyone. A MYGA gives a guaranteed rate; an FIA gives index-linked growth with a 0% floor, which may beat or trail the MYGA depending on markets.

Can you lose money in a fixed index annuity?

Not from index declines, which are credited as 0%. You can lose money by surrendering early (surrender charges) or through fees for optional riders.

Why would I choose a MYGA over an FIA?

For certainty and simplicity: you know your exact return in advance, and there are no caps or participation rates for the carrier to change.

Tom Enstice
Tom EnsticePrincipal and founder of Buy Insured. In investment services since 1977, including nearly four decades as a First Vice President at Morgan Stanley. More about Tom · BrokerCheck

Free rate quote

Get your confirmed rate.

Rates change with the market. Tell us what you're working with and Tom will quote today's best guaranteed rate for your state and term.

Call Tom directly

(609) 927-4700

Office

222 New Road, Central Park East, Suite 505
Linwood, NJ 08221

Meetings

By phone, at our Linwood office, or at your home anywhere within driving distance of the South Jersey Shore.