BuyInsured.org, It’s insured!

Guide

What happens when a MYGA matures

At the end of a MYGA’s guarantee period you get a short window to decide what happens next. Miss it and the carrier decides for you, often at a much lower rate.

Key points

  • Most MYGAs give a short window, often 30 days, at the end of the term.
  • You can withdraw, renew, or 1035 exchange to a new annuity.
  • Doing nothing usually means an automatic renewal at the carrier’s rate.
  • A 1035 exchange avoids tax on years of deferred interest.
Guarantee periodrate locked, surrender schedule appliesWindowdecideWithdrawRenew1035 to new MYGA

The end of the term and the “window”

A multi-year guaranteed annuity locks a rate for a set number of years. When that period ends, most contracts open a short window, commonly 30 days, during which you can take your money out with no surrender charge or move it elsewhere. The insurance company is required to send you notice before the term ends, but these letters are easy to miss.

Check your contract for the exact window. It is listed in the contract under renewal, the end of the surrender period or the guarantee period.

Your three options

1. Withdraw the money

You can take some or all of the value. On a non-IRA contract, the interest portion is taxable as ordinary income in the year you withdraw it. If you are under 59½, earnings may face a 10% IRS penalty. Inside an IRA, the full withdrawal is taxable unless you transfer it to another IRA.

2. Renew with the same carrier

Many contracts offer a renewal rate for a new guarantee period, or roll into a one-year rate that resets annually. Renewal rates are not always competitive with new-money rates, so compare before you accept.

3. Move to a new annuity with a 1035 exchange

A 1035 exchange moves the full value directly into a new annuity with no tax due. This is how most savers lock in a fresh multi-year rate, currently up to 6.25%, without triggering tax on years of deferred interest.

What happens if you do nothing

If the window closes without instructions, the contract typically renews automatically. Depending on the product, that may mean a new multi-year term with a fresh surrender schedule, or a one-year renewal rate that may be close to the contract’s minimum guaranteed rate. Either way, your money is no longer free to move without a surrender charge until the next window.

Tip: Put your maturity date on the calendar 60 days ahead. Buy Insured clients get a call from Tom before their window opens.

How to compare a renewal offer

Ask your current carrier for its renewal rate in writing, then compare it with the best new MYGA rates for the same term. If a new contract pays meaningfully more, a 1035 exchange usually makes sense. If the renewal rate is competitive and you like the carrier, renewing is simple.

Guarantee termRate$100k grows toYearly income on $100k
2-year fixed annuity5.15%$110,565$5,150
3-year fixed annuity6.00%$119,102$6,000
4-year fixed annuity5.70%$124,825$5,700
5-year fixed annuity6.15%$134,772$6,150
6-year fixed annuity5.90%$141,051$5,900
7-year fixed annuity6.15%$151,859$6,150
10-year fixed annuity6.25%$183,354$6,250

Frequently asked questions

How long is the window when a MYGA matures?

It varies by contract, but 30 days is common. Your contract and the carrier’s maturity notice state the exact dates.

Do I pay taxes when my MYGA matures?

Not if you renew or 1035 exchange. Tax is due only on the interest you actually withdraw, or on the full withdrawal from an IRA that isn’t transferred.

Can I roll a matured MYGA into a new MYGA?

Yes. A 1035 exchange moves the full value into a new annuity without tax, and it is the usual way to lock a new multi-year rate.

Will my MYGA renew automatically?

Usually, yes, if you take no action during the window. The renewal terms and rate are set by the carrier and may be lower than new-contract rates.

Tom Enstice
Tom EnsticePrincipal and founder of Buy Insured. In investment services since 1977, including nearly four decades as a First Vice President at Morgan Stanley. More about Tom · BrokerCheck

Free rate quote

Get your confirmed rate.

Rates change with the market. Tell us what you're working with and Tom will quote today's best guaranteed rate for your state and term.

Call Tom directly

(609) 927-4700

Office

222 New Road, Central Park East, Suite 505
Linwood, NJ 08221

Meetings

By phone, at our Linwood office, or at your home anywhere within driving distance of the South Jersey Shore.