BuyInsured.org, It’s insured!

Guide

1035 exchange: move an annuity tax-free

If you own an older annuity paying a low rate, a 1035 exchange lets you move it to a new contract without paying tax on the interest it has built up.

Key points

  • Moves an annuity to a new annuity with no tax due.
  • Funds must transfer directly between insurers.
  • Watch the old contract’s surrender charges and any benefits you would give up.
  • Best timing is usually at maturity or after the surrender period.
Old annuity2.50%New MYGA6.15%1035no tax due

What a 1035 exchange is

Section 1035 of the Internal Revenue Code lets you exchange one annuity contract for another without recognizing a taxable gain. Your tax-deferred earnings carry over into the new contract, and you pay tax only when you eventually withdraw them.

Life insurance policies can also be exchanged into annuities under the same section, but an annuity cannot be exchanged into a life insurance policy.

How it works

  1. Choose the new annuity and complete its application, marked as a 1035 exchange.
  2. Sign transfer forms. The new carrier requests the funds directly from the old carrier.
  3. The money moves company to company. You never take possession of it; if you did, it would be a taxable withdrawal.
  4. The new contract is issued, keeping the original cost basis from the old one.

Ownership generally needs to stay the same: the owner of the old contract should be the owner of the new one.

What to check first

  • Surrender charges on the old contract. Exchanging during its surrender period can cost more than the rate improvement gains. The best time is usually at maturity or after surrender charges end.
  • Benefits you would give up, such as a guaranteed income rider or an enhanced death benefit.
  • The new surrender schedule. A new contract starts a new surrender period.
  • The rate gap. Moving from 2.50% to 6.15% on $200,000 is roughly $7,300 more interest a year.

When a 1035 exchange makes sense

Common situations include an old fixed annuity renewing at a low rate, a MYGA reaching its maturity window, or a variable annuity with high fees where you now want guarantees. Tom will review your current contract and show the numbers before you decide.

Frequently asked questions

Is a 1035 exchange taxable?

No, when done correctly as a direct transfer between insurance companies. Tax is deferred until you take withdrawals from the new contract.

Can I 1035 exchange into a MYGA?

Yes. Exchanging an older annuity into a new multi-year guaranteed annuity is one of the most common uses.

Can I do a partial 1035 exchange?

Yes, partial exchanges are allowed, though some carriers have their own rules. Tax rules for partial exchanges are more complex, so check with your tax professional.

Do I pay a surrender charge on a 1035 exchange?

The old carrier can still apply its surrender charge if the contract is within its surrender period. That is why timing matters.

Sources: IRS: 26 U.S. Code § 1035 (via Cornell LII)

Tom Enstice
Tom EnsticePrincipal and founder of Buy Insured. In investment services since 1977, including nearly four decades as a First Vice President at Morgan Stanley. More about Tom · BrokerCheck

Free rate quote

Get your confirmed rate.

Rates change with the market. Tell us what you're working with and Tom will quote today's best guaranteed rate for your state and term.

Call Tom directly

(609) 927-4700

Office

222 New Road, Central Park East, Suite 505
Linwood, NJ 08221

Meetings

By phone, at our Linwood office, or at your home anywhere within driving distance of the South Jersey Shore.