For New Jersey savers
- Top fixed annuity rates for NJ residents currently reach 6.25%.
- Annuity interest isn't taxed while it stays in the contract; NJ taxes withdrawals, with a retirement exclusion for many residents 62+.
- New Jersey gives annuity buyers a free look period to review and return a contract.
- Buy Insured is in Linwood, NJ. Meet in person anywhere around the South Jersey Shore.
New Jersey fixed annuity rates
These are the top multi-year guaranteed annuity rates Buy Insured can currently quote. Every product we quote to a New Jersey resident is one the carrier is approved to sell in New Jersey.
| Guarantee term | Rate | $100k grows to | Yearly income on $100k |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2-year fixed annuity | 5.15% | $110,565 | $5,150 |
| 3-year fixed annuity | 6.00% | $119,102 | $6,000 |
| 4-year fixed annuity | 5.70% | $124,825 | $5,700 |
| 5-year fixed annuity | 6.15% | $134,772 | $6,150 |
| 6-year fixed annuity | 5.90% | $141,051 | $5,900 |
| 7-year fixed annuity | 6.15% | $151,859 | $6,150 |
| 10-year fixed annuity | 6.25% | $183,354 | $6,250 |
Top guaranteed rates Buy Insured can currently quote, as of November 2026. Value assumes $100,000 with interest left to compound annually. Rates vary by state, carrier and deposit amount and can change daily. Call (609) 927-4700 for a confirmed quote.
Why annuity rates differ by state
Insurance is regulated state by state. A carrier has to file each annuity product with the New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance before it can be sold here, and not every product, or every rate tier, is available in every state. That is why a national rate list can show a rate you cannot actually buy in New Jersey.
When you request a quote, Tom checks the products approved for New Jersey residents across the 55+ carriers we work with, then shows you the best rate available for your term and deposit, along with each carrier's financial strength rating.
How New Jersey taxes annuities
Annuity interest grows tax-deferred, for federal and New Jersey purposes, as long as it stays inside the contract. When you withdraw, the taxable part is reported as income on your New Jersey return.
Many retirees pay little or no New Jersey tax on that income because of the state's pension and retirement income exclusion. According to the New Jersey Division of Taxation, you may qualify if you or your spouse were 62 or older (or disabled under Social Security guidelines) at the end of the tax year and your total income was $150,000 or less. For tax year 2025, joint filers with total income of $100,000 or less can exclude up to $100,000 of pension, annuity and IRA income, and single filers up to $75,000, with partial exclusions between $100,001 and $150,000.
New Jersey does not tax Social Security benefits. We explain the details, with examples, in Are annuities taxed in New Jersey?
Source: NJ Division of Taxation, Retirement Income Exclusions. Tax rules change; confirm with your tax professional.
Consumer protections for New Jersey annuity buyers
- Free look period. You can review a new annuity contract and return it for a full refund within the free look period, at least 10 days in New Jersey.
- Suitability review. Before recommending an annuity, the agent and insurer must review whether it fits your needs, finances and objectives.
- Disclosure and buyer's guide. You receive a disclosure document and buyer's guide explaining surrender charges, guarantees and fees before you buy.
- Licensing. Anyone selling annuities in New Jersey must hold a New Jersey insurance license. You can check Tom's securities background on FINRA BrokerCheck.
Fixed annuities in South Jersey and Atlantic County

Buy Insured is based at 222 New Road, Central Park East, Suite 505 in Linwood, a few minutes from Somers Point and Northfield and a short drive from Atlantic City and Ocean City. Tom Enstice has worked with Jersey Shore families since 1977 and will come to you anywhere within driving distance.
We regularly help savers in Linwood, Somers Point, Northfield, Margate, Ventnor, Atlantic City, Egg Harbor Township, Galloway, Mays Landing, Ocean City, Sea Isle City, Cape May Court House, Hammonton, Brigantine, Absecon and Toms River.
Looking for an annuity advisor near you? Get directions and contact details, or call (609) 927-4700.
New Jersey annuity questions
What are the best annuity rates in New Jersey?
As of November 2026, the top fixed annuity rates Buy Insured can quote for New Jersey residents run up to 6.25%, depending on term. Because carriers price by state, call (609) 927-4700 to confirm the best rate available for your deposit.
Are annuities taxed in New Jersey?
Yes. Taxable annuity withdrawals count as New Jersey income, but annuity interest is not taxed while it stays in the contract. Residents 62 and older with total income of $150,000 or less may exclude some or all pension, annuity and IRA income under the state retirement income exclusion. See our full guide: Are annuities taxed in New Jersey?
Do New Jersey annuities have a free look period?
Yes. New Jersey gives annuity buyers a free look period, at least 10 days, to review the contract and return it for a full refund of premium.
Can I meet with someone in person in South Jersey?
Yes. Tom Enstice meets clients at the Buy Insured office at 222 New Road, Central Park East, Suite 505, Linwood, NJ, or at your home anywhere within driving distance of the South Jersey Shore.
Do I have to buy from a New Jersey company?
No. You can buy from any insurance carrier approved to sell that product in New Jersey. Buy Insured compares 55+ carriers and only shows products available to New Jersey residents.

