Key points
- A MYGA is the closest alternative to a CD: fixed rate, fixed term.
- Fixed annuities grow tax-deferred; CDs are taxed yearly.
- Treasuries and savings suit shorter-term money.
- Many retirees use both CDs and fixed annuities.
The main alternatives to CDs
| Option | Backed by | Taxes | Access |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed annuity (MYGA) | Insurance company | Tax-deferred | Free withdrawal yearly; surrender charge above |
| U.S. Treasuries | U.S. government | Federal tax yearly; exempt from state income tax | Can sell before maturity at market price |
| High-yield savings | FDIC insurance | Taxed yearly | Anytime; rate can change any day |
| Money market funds | Not insured; invests in short-term debt | Taxed yearly | Anytime |
| Fixed index annuity | Insurance company | Tax-deferred | Like a MYGA; returns vary with an index |
Of these, a fixed annuity is the closest match to a CD: one deposit, one guaranteed rate, one fixed term, currently up to 6.25%.
Why many retirees choose fixed annuities
- Guaranteed rates for 2 to 10 years, often higher than CDs of the same length.
- Tax deferral: you choose when to pay tax, which can help manage income in retirement.
- No market risk to principal.
- Penalty-free access to part of the money each year on most contracts.
Run your own numbers in the fixed annuity vs CD calculator.
When to keep a CD
CDs still make sense for money you need within a year or two, for amounts you want covered by FDIC insurance, and for anyone under 59½ who may need to withdraw earnings. Many retirees keep a CD or savings cushion for near-term spending and place the rest in fixed annuities.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best alternative to a CD for retirees?
For a CD-like experience with a fixed rate and term, a multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) is the closest alternative, with tax-deferred growth. Treasuries and high-yield savings are alternatives for shorter-term money.
Is a fixed annuity safer than a CD?
They are protected differently: CDs by FDIC insurance up to its limits, fixed annuities by the insurer’s claims-paying ability. Both protect your principal from market losses.
What happens to my CD money if I move it to an annuity?
You would fund the annuity with the CD proceeds when the CD matures, avoiding the bank’s early-withdrawal penalty. IRA CDs should move by direct transfer.

