BuyInsured.org, It’s insured!

Guide

CD alternatives for retirees

When CDs come up for renewal at lower rates, conservative savers look for options with the same safety and a better return. Here is how the main alternatives compare.

Key points

  • A MYGA is the closest alternative to a CD: fixed rate, fixed term.
  • Fixed annuities grow tax-deferred; CDs are taxed yearly.
  • Treasuries and savings suit shorter-term money.
  • Many retirees use both CDs and fixed annuities.
CDtaxed every yearFixed annuityup to 6.25%tax-deferred

The main alternatives to CDs

OptionBacked byTaxesAccess
Fixed annuity (MYGA)Insurance companyTax-deferredFree withdrawal yearly; surrender charge above
U.S. TreasuriesU.S. governmentFederal tax yearly; exempt from state income taxCan sell before maturity at market price
High-yield savingsFDIC insuranceTaxed yearlyAnytime; rate can change any day
Money market fundsNot insured; invests in short-term debtTaxed yearlyAnytime
Fixed index annuityInsurance companyTax-deferredLike a MYGA; returns vary with an index

Of these, a fixed annuity is the closest match to a CD: one deposit, one guaranteed rate, one fixed term, currently up to 6.25%.

Why many retirees choose fixed annuities

  • Guaranteed rates for 2 to 10 years, often higher than CDs of the same length.
  • Tax deferral: you choose when to pay tax, which can help manage income in retirement.
  • No market risk to principal.
  • Penalty-free access to part of the money each year on most contracts.

Run your own numbers in the fixed annuity vs CD calculator.

When to keep a CD

CDs still make sense for money you need within a year or two, for amounts you want covered by FDIC insurance, and for anyone under 59½ who may need to withdraw earnings. Many retirees keep a CD or savings cushion for near-term spending and place the rest in fixed annuities.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best alternative to a CD for retirees?

For a CD-like experience with a fixed rate and term, a multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) is the closest alternative, with tax-deferred growth. Treasuries and high-yield savings are alternatives for shorter-term money.

Is a fixed annuity safer than a CD?

They are protected differently: CDs by FDIC insurance up to its limits, fixed annuities by the insurer’s claims-paying ability. Both protect your principal from market losses.

What happens to my CD money if I move it to an annuity?

You would fund the annuity with the CD proceeds when the CD matures, avoiding the bank’s early-withdrawal penalty. IRA CDs should move by direct transfer.

Tom Enstice
Tom EnsticePrincipal and founder of Buy Insured. In investment services since 1977, including nearly four decades as a First Vice President at Morgan Stanley. More about Tom · BrokerCheck

Free rate quote

Get your confirmed rate.

Rates change with the market. Tell us what you're working with and Tom will quote today's best guaranteed rate for your state and term.

Call Tom directly

(609) 927-4700

Office

222 New Road, Central Park East, Suite 505
Linwood, NJ 08221

Meetings

By phone, at our Linwood office, or at your home anywhere within driving distance of the South Jersey Shore.